Why do all the charities have to be run by Christians?


“Why are all the charities run by Christians?”

Of course I’m fully aware that it is untrue to say that “all of the charities are run by Christians”! In fact, I was initially at a loss as to how to respond to the question when it was put to me.

My friend lives on a disability pension. Because he lives on a very low income, he avails himself of a range of community services in the local area. He has observed, with annoyance, that there is an overwhelming majority of Christians involved in running and staffing these services, including as volunteers. So he asked why, and whether it really has to be so.


The complaint.

“Why are all the charities run by Christians?” he asks. In fact, it’s a complaint. He doesn’t like it. These Christians keep wanting to pray for him and tell him about God, and he says that he’s not interested.

When I had first met this friend (at the Chat Room), he was complaining that someone had prayed for him (he had an injured arm), and that he didn’t like it. I took a close interest, explaining that it was actually rude of the person to do that because it is most certainly considered good manners to ask someone if they would like you to pray. He replied, “Oh, they asked. I said it was ok. I mean, I didn’t feel right saying no…”

Ok, that’s a little different…

So then I explained that “no, I’m not comfortable with that”, is actually a perfectly acceptable response. I then waxed a little about what prayer means among Christians, and how it is a very palpable expression of care and concerned love, to offer to stand beside someone, before God, and plead their case on their behalf. He moved away with tears in his eyes. Because that was the real question…

As it happens, within five minutes he returned seeking a private audience, which I promptly organised. He broke down weeping, and begging/demanding of me, “You prove to me that there’s a God“. His life experience had made it hard for him to conceive of a loving God. I refused his request (to provide proof), and we had a great talk about faith, and tragedy, and the goodness of God.

But I digress..

The response.

When my friend asked the question, I knew it was a complaint. He was just as much saying, “Why can’t some of these charities be run by people who aren’t Christians?” Because he would prefer that.

So what do you say to that?

Initially, I deconstructed the question, denying the premise: Not all charities are run by Christians! I know plenty of wonderfully community-minded people who are not Christians, and many are involved in charitable work… I quickly saw how useless this response was,  however, because it didn’t address the real question.

Secondly, I tried to explain that in fact, anybody could run these charities (which include running free barbecues for the homeless in the local parks, for example), but that it just happened that Christians were doing it. I as I went on, I began to realise that the statistics actually don’t support this hypothesis: Christians are in the minority in the community, but are massively overrepresented in coal-face charitable acts.

But it wasn’t helping him anyway. What he was really asking was, “What’s the difference between a Christian and a non-Christian, which can account for this surprising statistical anomaly?”

Caught off guard (an unfamiliar sensation for me), I blundered around, talking about how Christians are taught routinely about the importance of charitable work, whereas non-Christians are not, and that this accounts for the difference. It was a stupid answer, and my friend was discerning enough to recognise, in his own way, that it was completely inadequate for his purposes. He went away, politely acknowledging my response,  but unconvinced.

What’s the answer?

The real answer, which I am ashamed to say I didn’t come up with on the spot, as to why there is a massive over-representation of Christians in charitable services to the community, is simply this: God cares.

The people of God flow to those places where God’s heart dwells. God has a special concern in matters such as the relief of pain, worship, prayer, illumination, and community, so those activities naturally attract Christians. The charities are flooded with Christians because God’s will is being expressed by those charities, and the call of the Christian is to participate in God’s will.

I’ll see my friend some time, probably in the next few weeks. I’ll give him the real answer then. It’ll bless him.

In the mean time, I counsel myself, as ever, to resist the urge to answer the questions that people are presenting, and instead answer the question that they’re really asking. That was one significant identifiable attribute of Jesus’ ministry, and it accounts for much of the positive responses I enjoy among people who come asking questions.


Other posts in this series:

Marketplace Christianity – In a Marketplace!

Posted on May 29th, 2012 - By Kevin Bennett - 5 Comments

What is Marketplace Christianity really? Generally, the term "Marketplace Christianity" is used to describe the way in which a believer can…

Continue Reading

Street Links 2012 – God does not show favouritism.

Posted on Jun 6th, 2012 - By Kevin Bennett - 1 Comment

Has not God chosen those who are poor in the eyes of the world to be rich in faith and to inherit the kingdom he promised those who love him? (Jas…

Continue Reading

Evangelism: What is it? Do you have to do it?

Posted on Jun 12th, 2012 - By Kevin Bennett - 0 Comments

What is Evangelism? Do you have to do it? Read on... perhaps you already do! Summary: Jesus’ “Great Commission” of Matthew 28:18-20 is,…

Continue Reading

Titles: “Who do the crowds say I am?”, “Who do you say I am?”, “I do not accept human testimony”.

Posted on Jun 13th, 2012 - By Kevin Bennett - 0 Comments

What's in a name? That which we call a rose, by any other name would smell as sweet! How important are titles? I am given various titles by various…

Continue Reading

Why do all the charities have to be run by Christians?

Posted on Jun 18th, 2012 - By Kevin Bennett - 0 Comments

"Why are all the charities run by Christians?" Of course I'm fully aware that it is untrue to say that "all of the charities are run by Christians"!…

Continue Reading

The Ministry: “I assign to you, as my Father assigned to me, a kingdom…”

Posted on Jul 10th, 2012 - By Kevin Bennett - 1 Comment

What possible value can come from simply "being there"? I've begun a habit of sitting in the Ipswich Mall every Tuesday. Several people join me…

Continue Reading

Heaven: “a banquet of aged wine — the best of meats and the finest of wines”

Posted on Aug 8th, 2012 - By Kevin Bennett - 0 Comments

Heaven as "a banquet" There are numerous Biblical texts which liken heaven, in various ways, to a great banquet. But how  is this properly used in…

Continue Reading

A Five-Year-Old Junkie and the Hungry Bandit

Posted on Aug 17th, 2012 - By Kevin Bennett - 0 Comments

People are Awesome How do you describe a day in which you meet not one, but two very special human beings? Last Tuesday, as is my custom, I…

Continue Reading

You will know the truth, and the truth will set you free (Jn 8:32)

Posted on Aug 26th, 2012 - By Kevin Bennett - 0 Comments

If the Son sets you free, you will be free indeed (Jn 8:36) I have a friend who has been set free by the truth. This is from her story. The story…

Continue Reading

“Mission to the Marginalised”…?

Posted on Jan 29th, 2013 - By Kevin Bennett - 0 Comments

How many roads must a man walk down before they call him a missionary? I was invited recently to talk under the heading "Mission to the…

Continue Reading

Street Theology: Justification by Faith

Posted on Mar 7th, 2013 - By Kevin Bennett - 4 Comments

How Biblical Justification Looks "On the Street" Everybody loves being right. It's even better when you are recognised as being right in front of…

Continue Reading

Evangelism: A View from the Inside

Posted on Apr 2nd, 2013 - By Kevin Bennett - 0 Comments

A State of Being: Freedom I was reflecting, as I often do, on what the chances are that I will be able to impart my joy to others before I…

Continue Reading

Sonny with a Chance

Posted on Jun 21st, 2013 - By Kevin Bennett - 0 Comments

The Bible: A Book of Comfort My friend Sonny saw me in the Mall today and we had a bit of a chat. He said something very wise, which I pointed out…

Continue Reading

Join us in Street Ministry

Posted on Jul 1st, 2013 - By Kevin Bennett - 6 Comments

You too, can Preach to the Street I have recently been producing and distributing little cards which contain a single Bible verse, and a very…

Continue Reading

On Earth as it is in Heaven

Posted on Jul 10th, 2013 - By Kevin Bennett - 0 Comments

To What shall I Compare the Kingdom of God? The kingdom of God is coming to the street subculture of Ipswich. How can I describe it? How can I…

Continue Reading

It Starts: The Kingdom of God is Germinating in Ipswich

Posted on Oct 15th, 2013 - By Kevin Bennett - 11 Comments

October 2013: It Starts. I need to record some of the things that have been happening because God is making himself known in remarkable ways in…

Continue Reading

Will not God grant justice to his chosen ones who cry to him day and night? Will he delay long in helping them? – Luke 18:7

Posted on Nov 4th, 2013 - By Kevin Bennett - 1 Comment

Persisent Prayer - An illustration I just found this audio. I recorded it twelve months ago, and kept it switched to "Private" in SoundCloud. It…

Continue Reading

Evangelism: A Revolution

Posted on Nov 13th, 2013 - By Kevin Bennett - 0 Comments

That Old Question: What really is Evangelism? I've posted a couple of things previously which reveal my unorthodox take on what 'Evangelism'…

Continue Reading

Reflections on the Trip of a Lifetime: Day 1-2 Brisbane – Sydney – Abu Dhabi – Athens

Posted on Jan 11th, 2014 - By Kevin Bennett - 2 Comments

Brisbane - Sydney - Abu Dhabi - Athens Day 1 is mostly travel. In fact, it's hard to define what, precisely, is a "day" when you cross so many time…

Continue Reading

If there’s any “Church life” in twenty years’ time… what will it look like?

Posted on Dec 9th, 2014 - By Kevin Bennett - 0 Comments

The Church will not be the same in 2035. What will it be like? I have great confidence that the Church will be healthy and strong in 2035, because…

Continue Reading

In The Mall… What’s it all about?

Posted on Dec 28th, 2014 - By Kevin Bennett - 0 Comments

Introduction I was asked to compile a brief story about what I've been up to. Much of this story comes from other blog posts, but there's also some…

Continue Reading

facebook comments:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.